• This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Top 5 Local Only Restaurants

HomeTop 5s in Siesta KeyTop 5 Local Only Restaurants

When a sunny getaway is calling your name, planning a trip to scenic Siesta Key promises to be the right decision every time. Half the fun of a trip this way is discovering the delightful eateries to pair with your beach experiences. While there are plenty to choose from, the following are five local Siesta Key restaurants that you won’t want to miss.

The Orange Octopus

Situated at 1220 Old Stickney Point Road, The Orange Octopus is the perfect place to find yourself in Siesta Key whether you have a sweet tooth to satisfy or you require a caffeine kick to keep the day of fun rolling along successfully. The Orange Octopus is a local favorite stop where it’s easy to enjoy everything from ice cream and coffee to delicious, handcrafted treats in abundance. This savory stop is open daily between 11:00 am until 11:00 pm, making it a practically all-hours eatery when you’re up for putting a sweet twist on your day. This family-owned stop offers counter service and 24 flavors that are slow-churned right in store. Bring the entire family and don’t be surprised if you find yourself wanting to return time and again to one of the best restaurants in Siesta Key!

Village Café

When dining beachside sounds like the perfect way to start your day, or a delightful stop to add to your afternoon itinerary, the Village Café has you covered. This inviting local eatery is located at 5133 Ocean Boulevard in Siesta Key and offers up an abundance of breakfast and lunch fare to choose from that always gets served up with a side of friendly service included! This charming stop sits close to souvenir shops so you can pair your meal with some retail therapy too. When you drop by, be sure to try the eggs and bacon paired with French toast or even an order of Nutella fritters! If you find yourself here as part of the lunch crowd, be sure to indulge in options that range from sandwiches and fresh salads to mouthwatering burgers and grilled grouper too. Village Café hosts a full kids’ menu if you drop by with little ones in tow. This family-owned establishment has been a Siesta Key favorite since 1995 and is open daily between 7:30 am and 2:00 pm.

The Lobster Pot

Enjoying a taste of coastal Maine isn’t hard to do when you drop by The Lobster Pot in Siesta Key. This sensational seafood stop is found at 215 Canal Road and was inspired by a restaurant of the same name that was first set up on Cape Cod all the way back in the 1940s. Today, guests looking to indulge their tastebuds and enjoy a side of east coast charm right in the heart of Siesta Key can find both opportunities waiting at The Lobster Pot. Savory selections served up here are fished out of the surrounding Florida waters, but also imported right from Maine for an even greater touch of authenticity! The Lobster Pot is open to the dining public Monday through Thursday from 11:30 am until 9:00 pm with extended weekend hours until 9:30 pm.

Summer House Steak and Seafood

Siesta Key visitors on the hunt for a place where they can dine local in a setting that speaks to elegance too will find everything they’re looking for and even more at Summer House Steak and Seafood. Situated at 149 Avenida Messina, Summer House Steak and Seafood is a great place to dine when you’re looking to enjoy a refined meal of hand-cut steak or seafood selections in a setting that pairs coastal charm with cozy seating options. The fantastic flavors found here are only rivaled by the fun of admiring the restaurant’s on-site fish tank which holds up to 1,000 gallons of water and is an impressive 14 feet long! Summer House Steak and Seafood is open Monday through Sunday from 4:00 pm until 10:00 pm for dinner service.

One of the Best Restaurants in Siesta Key: Siesta Key Oyster Bar

Fun, flavor, and a fantastic atmosphere awaits when you choose to dine at Siesta Key Oyster Bar. Situated at scenic 5238 Ocean Boulevard, Siesta Key Oyster Bar is a beach eatery that focuses on elevating the island experience for diners at every turn. Taking a seat on the spacious patio offers up spectacular views which are best paired with one of their many mouthwatering menu options. Guests can pick and choose from options that include oysters, chicken wings, burgers, jalapeno poppers, mozzarella sticks, and more! No matter what you order up, make sure to add a handcrafted cocktail to the mix and end your day on a savory note. The Siesta Key Oyster Bar is open Monday through Thursday from 11:00 am until Midnight and Saturdays from 11:00 am until 2:00 am.

Book Your Stay Today

There’s never been a better time to enjoy Siesta Key. When you’re ready to turn travel plans into a reality, Rent Siesta Key can help. We have the rental options that take your trip to the next level of excellence. Reach out today to learn more about Siesta Key restaurants and our rentals!