• This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Rent Siesta Key Property Reviews

HomeWho We AreRent Siesta Key Property Reviews

Here we have compiled a list of reviews starting with the most recent submission through our website. This is a great tool to find a property with the best reviews. With well over 15,000 reviews collected, Rent Siesta Key is rated one of the highest vacation rental companies in the central gulf coast area of Florida. We do our best to make sure the property you have rented for your vacation is clean, organized, and without any issues prior to your arrival. with our no-hassle check-in process, you can simply arrive at the property and begin to enjoy your vacation. Single family homes and condominiums are complex pieces of real property and issues do arise from time to time. In this event, we will work diligently to rectify any issue that is within our scope of work as quickly as possible.

Our owners as well as our team get very excited to receive glowing 5-star reviews, but the 3 and 4 star reviews help us and the property owners improve on any deficiencies and improve the quality that we strive to achieve with every rental.

What Our Guests Are Saying

Great Time

Hello, My wife and I, Chris & Mike, stayed at the Holiday House at 1011 Crescent St. #1, last week. We had a wonderful time and would like you to pass onto the owners the following: Rooms were great, clean and well furnished. Plenty of linens/towels, high quality cookware (my wife likes to cook) and modern kitchen and bath. Our kitchen has the same backsplash tile and our shower has a similar pebble stone floor. While there, the local maintenance man stopped by, the pool service was done, the Orkin man was there and a couple of guys cut dead plants and cleaned up. Patio and pool area is great, but a few suggestions: Need a handrail at one end to facilitate going down and up the steps into the pool. My wife is only 62, but needed my hand every time. In our 7 trips to Siesta Key, this is the first place that we want to come back to next year. I’m sure we’ll be in touch when the time comes. WE LOVED IT. Thanks for everything.

By: Mike

Great holiday

Nice place close to the beach.

By: Carsten

Rental agency was very responsive

I found Rent Siesta Key to be a very helpful and responsive agency.

By: Susan

Bay Oaks - E01

All in all everything was as advertised.

By: Al

Peaceful neighborhood close to everything

Really enjoyed our stay in Beach Bungalow A. Plenty of room and the pool was fabulous. Only 3 blocks from the beach in a quiet neighborhood of beautiful homes. Closer to the bay side to watch the sunrise from your window. Free shuttle stop 3blicks away to take you anywhere on the island. Bridge street was only a 15 minute walk to get coffee in the morning and do a bit of shopping. The only negative if you have small children with you is the pool is literally right outside your door. I was so afraid my 2 year old granddaughter would wake up and open one of the two doors and slip our without us hearing her(she quickly learned how to unlock the doo). . We put a bar stool in front of the doors to make additional noise in case she tried something. A chain lock up high would be an easy fix for added security. Remember that supplies such as trash bags, paper towels and toilet paper are not supplied so you might have to buy some additional things. Overall I highly recommend staying here.

By: Melissa

Best vacation ever!

We loved this little cottage. The location was absolutely perfect and it had everything that we need

By: Nancy

Funboard B Review by the Hughes'

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. The unit was clean and neat. The second time we have rented this unit and even with the activities limited by CoVid 19 we were able to walk on the beach

By: Richard

Home away from home with a view

Needs some updating. Great space and so close to the beach.

By: Louanne

Excellent vacation getaway studio apartment

No problems. Good communication

By: Joe & Ranck

Great location. Easy beach access and stores

We loved the location - the beach walk close and restaurants and shops walking distance.

By: Pat 03/02/2020

Beautiful home

House was beautiful, spacious, clean and had every amenity that we needed. Great location, the only downside is it’s right next to the busy road and you get a lot of traffic noise especially at weekend, however, this didn’t spoil our stay and is only a minor point. Would stay here again and would recommend.

By: Joanne


The property is nice. Slightly dated but clean and functional.the permanent residents of the property are are pleasant and we enjoyed their company. Would rent again!

By: Thomas

Location is perfect

Great location the unit was clean and the managers were very responsive. We had trouble with the grill and a new one was soon delivered! The pool is very nice and well maintained! We rented again for next year

By: Connie 03/09/2020

Holiday House 4

Awesome location. Well equipped rental. Very responsive maintenance staff.

By: James 03/09/2020

Longboard Condo Anna Marie Island- Great Stay

Thank you for a great visit to AMI. Starting on the 1st day when we were greeted by Adam the manager of the property throughout our visit the condo was a wonderful location for all activities in Holmes Beach. We could walk to the beach, to the stores near us and many restaurants in the area. The condo had a lot of room including a large living area and a dining room. The place came with beach equipment, 2 large TV's, and a nice kitchen set up. Plenty of room to move around. Great location!!!

By: Geoff 03/04/2020

Our Stay 2/2020

The Seagrove home is very spacious and would accommodate 6 people comfortably. The King beds and 2 full baths were great to have The house is located is in a very quiet, tropical neighborhood which is quite dog friendly. You need a flashlight to walk at night which we had to purchase (it is very dark) We rode our bikes to beautiful beach #2 which is a short distance from the village. Bicycles are not provided. The pool is a plus. However, it doesn’t get any sun so we needed the pool heater turned on in order to use it. We were disappointed that the entire property is shaded. You can’t relax or tan outside on this property. A couple of beach chairs and pool floaties are available. The kitchen is moderately equipped with plenty of storage But there is no unbreakable dishes or cups for children’s use. If you have any questions or concerns John is very helpful addressing them . We enjoyed our stay very much and are returning to Siesta Key next year!

By: Marlene 03/04/2020

Gulf Gate Getaway

We have enjoyed staying at this property for the past four years in February. We love sitting by the pool and enjoying the many water birds in the area. There are lounge chairs as well as two tables and chairs to use. We find the beds to be very comfortable. The location of this home is a huge plus. It is only 10 minutes to Siesta Key Beach and there are lots of restaurants nearby. The property manager was very helpful whenever we had a problem. We will be renting this home again.

By: Peter 03/03/2020

Screen Porch Heaven

We found this Paradise Beach West condo to have a great kitchen area but an even better screened in porch large enough to seat 6 people. It had "party lights" to add to the fun atmosphere. We used this area every day. Kitchen was well stocked & had large table w/bench seating and chairs. It was a quiet residential area with quick access to beach and had lots of shade trees. The only improvements I would suggest might be replacing some of the chairs on the screened in porch as they were not very sturdy or comfortable with very worn cushions and maybe a fresh coat of paint in kitchen area would be nice. Overall, we would highly recommend Paradise Beach West.

By: Kathy 03/02/2020

Family friendly home siesta key

Overall a nice property. in a great location. older home but nice amenities. great for big families and guests.

By: Jim 03/01/2020

Siesta Key Stay

Close to beach and pool easy to catch the trolley. The guys at rent siesta keys. We’re very helpful. This was our first FL stay.

By: Mark 03/01/2020

Our Stay

Overall a great stay however the backyard could be more presentable.

By: Michele

Clean condo with a beautiful view

Overall we enjoyed our stay in this 3-bedroom condo. We always looked forward to watching the sunset over the water. The condo was spotless when we arrived. I only wished there were more amenities in the kitchen like kitchen towels, mixing bowls, cookie sheets and hot pads. Luckily, when we did have a meal in, they were Costco type meals which just needed to be heated, otherwise, the appliances were modern so it was evident that the kitchen was updated. There are plenty of stores and restaurants near by which was a plus.

By: Barbara

Siesta Heron 7

A group of 6 friends stayed at Siesta Heron Unit 7. We were impressed with the cleanliness of our unit and the pretty view. With a few needed improvements, this unit would be much better for a group of adults. This is advertised as sleeping 8 people. A few necessary improvements are: More coffee mugs More wine glasses.

By: Jane

Slice of Paradise

Beautiful property great location love the boat dock and being able to use a boat everyday enjoyed the patio and cooking at my meals outside cool was fun to be able to cool off in.

By: Charles

Wonderful Property

We loved our stay!!! The property was spacious, exceptionally clean and well appointed. Short walk to Siesta Key Village. We are looking forward to coming back!!!

By: Tim & Kim