• This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Top 5 Fancy Restaurants

HomeTop 5s in Siesta KeyTop 5 Fancy Restaurants

Finding your way to Siesta Key any time of year in the name of a great getaway is always worth your while. Whether you’re looking forward to a vacation that revolves around outdoor adventure, or you have a heart for soaking up the sun from the sand, this is a destination that provides a place for it all. It’s also a destination filled with fantastic restaurants to enjoy! The following are the top 5 Siesta Key fancy restaurants to check out while you’re in town if upscale dining is an integral part of your getaway experience.

Dolce Italia

Making your way to Siesta Key, Florida is often an exercise in indulging in sun, sand, and surf. While there’s an assumption that a trip this way will include an abundance of shoreline-inspired fare, when Siesta Key fancy restaurants are top of mind, Italian selections are readily available at Dolce Italia. Situated at 6551 Gateway Avenue, Dolce Italia is a warm and welcoming stop where guests can enjoy everything from burrata and gnocchi, to clam linguini and rigatoni al pesto upon request. Much of the menu is inspired by cuisine that’s preferred and perfected in the Gulf of Naples. When you’re here, don’t leave without pairing your plate with the perfect Italian wine to match. Dolce Italia is open Wednesday through Saturday from 5:00 pm until 9:00 pm for dinner and reservations are highly recommended.

Café Gabbiano

The Italian tradition of delectable dining continues for guests visiting Siesta Key who make a dinner reservation at Café Gabbiano while they’re in town. Located at 5104 Ocean Boulevard, Café Gabbiano promises to provide a fine dining experience complete with friendly service and an inspired setting to indulge your tastebuds across a variety of Italian favorite dishes. Dinner is served between 5:00 pm and 10:00 pm daily and the menu here hosts everything from sauteed veal and poached pear to truffle pasta and braised ravioli just to name a few. Café Gabbiano is known for its extensive wine list and many guests are thrilled by the rustic-chic ambiance. Both cannoli and tiramisu are a must-try before you head out if you want to be sure to end your dining experience on a sweet note.

Miguel’s Restaurant

French and continental cuisine collide seamlessly for those looking to make the most of a fine dining experience at Miguel’s Restaurant. Easily found at 6631 Midnight Pass Road, Miguel’s Restaurant is open from 4:00 pm until 10:00 pm daily and offers up a cozy and eclectic place to enjoy an upscale meal. Whether you go with the escargot and steak tartare or the French Onion Soup and roasted duck, a meal at Miguel’s is nearly an art form in and of itself! Reservations are recommended at this popular stop which tends to fill up for dinner fast year-round.

Siesta Key Fine Dining at Ophelia’s on the Bay

Located at 9105 Midnight Pass Road, Ophelia’s on the Bay is a beautiful and elegant eatery to enjoy an upscale meal when you find yourself craving seafood in sophisticated surroundings. Dinner is served up daily from 5:00 pm until 10:00 pm and those who choose to settle in at Ophelia’s will find that the entrée and wine menu are vast and varied. Guests can choose to dine in the main dining room complete with floor-to-ceiling windows or head out to the sprawling bayside patio for an alfresco experience. The menu here features everything from calamari and Gulf shrimp to jumbo crab cakes and filet mignon cooked perfectly to taste.

Summer House Steak & Seafood

When an unforgettable meal is what you crave and you’re looking for the elegant surroundings to match, a dinner enjoyed at Summer House Steak & Seafood is found to be a highlight of Siesta Key fine dining on your stay. Situated at 149 Avenida Messina, Summer House Steak & Seafood is a fantastic and stylish locale where guests can settle into blue and white themed surroundings to enjoy steak, seafood, or a selection of both in style! This upscale dining location is known for their sustainable approach to steak as well as their innovative handcrafted cocktails made to match. Dinner is served with a reservation between 4:00 pm and 9:30 pm every night of the week with extended hours on Friday and Saturday until 10:30 pm. From oysters Rockefeller to diver scallops and the filet mignon in between, this is a stop you simply won’t want to miss out on.

Make the Most of a Siesta Key Getaway

When it’s time to unwind, relax, and kick back in shoreline style, there’s no better place to do exactly that than Siesta Key, Florida. As scenic as it is inviting, this vacation destination proves time and again to be truly one-of-a-kind! Knowing you have amazing rental accommodations in place to match the fun makes it all the better. When you’re ready to turn vacation plans into a reality Rent Siesta Key is here to help. Reach out today to learn more about our portfolio of property options. We can’t wait to welcome you to Siesta Key soon!