Rent Siesta Key Property Reviews
Here we have compiled a list of reviews by property name in alphabetical order. This is a great tool to find a property with the best reviews. With well over 1,000 reviews collected, Rent Siesta Key is rated one of the highest vacation rental companies in the central gulf coast area of Florida. We do our best to make sure the property you have rented for your vacation is clean, organized, and without any issues prior to your arrival. with our no-hassle check-in process, you can simply arrive at the property and begin to enjoy your vacation. Single family homes and condominiums are complex pieces of real property and issues do arise from time to time. In this event, we will work diligently to rectify any issue that is within our scope of work as quickly as possible.
Our owners as well as our team get very excited to receive glowing 5-star reviews, but the 3 and 4 star reviews help us and the property owners improve on any deficiencies and improve the quality that we strive to achieve with every rental.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyMylissa it was a pleasure to host your party and we look forward to your return visit! Don't hesitate to let us know if there is anything we can help you with in planning your next adventure or retreat in Siesta Key!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for staying with us Yuliya! We just put a new grill in this home, and will have the pillows inspected/replaced. We hope to see you again soon!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyBeverly we really appreciated the opportunity to host your stay, and are so glad to hear you enjoyed yourself. Thank you for leaving such an informative review - this really sums up the home nicely, and we are sure future guests will appreciate your acute insights. This home is quite popular for all of the reasons you mentioned, so don't hesitate to call us to make arrangements for next year. We look forward to seeing your family again soon on beautiful Siesta Key!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for choosing Rent Siesta Key, Mike! We are so glad you enjoyed the ideal location of this home, so close to Morton's gourmet supermarket and all of the great restaurants and shops of Siesta Village. Please come back and see us soon!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for choosing to stay at Avenida De Cortez property. We are glad to hear you enjoyed your stay getting away from the Ohio winter. Sitting out back on the patio is our favorite spot, wish we could enjoy it more often. We look forward to accommodating you next year!
Great location to everything in town and beach the property is well maintained and everyth8ng you need is available. We love it!!!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for your continued relationship and choosing to stay at Avenida De Cortez.
Just a block from the village a short walk to restaurants, shops and the beach. Although it was much larger than the 2 of us needed it is a very nice home and Very well maintained and everything you could ask for is there. Was like being at home but warmer!
Customer service was excellent! Had a question and they responded that day and even stopped by the next day to check on things.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for staying and we look forward to accommodating you on your next visit to Siesta Key. It was a pleasure.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank for choosing to stay. We know there are many options for your accommodations and we like to offer some perks that other may not, such as two bike. More can also be rented from the management company if needed.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for staying. We try our best to keep the unit as open yet comfortable as possible.
The house is roomy and easily fit our group of two couples. Great beds, good AC, plenty of space and adequately furnished. Fully functioning kitchen with enough pots and utensils for most.
Recommend this location.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for staying and the stellar review. The location is prime! We wish we could stay more often ourselves.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for choosing to stay at Avenida De Cortez. We are glad to hear you enjoyed your stay this past September and look forward to accommodating you again in your next visit to Siesta Key.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for staying at Avenida De Cortez and we appreciate the great review!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for staying at Avenida De Cortez property. Glad to hear you enjoyed the property and the area. We look forward to accommodating you in the future.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for staying at Avenida De Cortez property. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and look forward to accommodating you next season.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for staying and the great review.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyGlad to hear you enjoyed your stay at our vacation rental.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyGlad you enjoyed your stay!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for the rave review. Look forward to accommodating you in the future.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyNot sure what needs updating, the entire unit was remodeled just 3 years ago from flooring, to cabinets, to stainless steel appliances, to full bathroom remodels...
Place was very clean and well stocked in terms of towels and kitchen equipment.
We loved the view from the living room and the location was excellent. A 5 minute drive to the village (lots of transport available if you don’t want to drive).
Pool was fine, we ended up using the one at our in-laws house but this was to spend time with our family.
Overall, I really loved the time in Siesta Key and couldn’t fault the accommodation.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyOliver thank you for taking the time to share your experience for the benefit of future guests. We are so glad to hear you enjoyed the home and had a good time on the island. Please come again soon!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyArmand you definitely hit the nail on the head! Thank you for staying with us, and for leaving such a great review for the benefit of future guests. We hope to see you again soon!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyIt was a pleasure to host your stay Tina! We are so glad you were able to make use of that great dock, and that you enjoyed the terrific location of this home. Please come back soon!
A couple of minor niggles. The light and fan on the lounge balcony didn’t work which was a shame as that one had mosquito protection for the evenings and the stairs were quite uncomfortable to walk down due to the edgings hitting the balls of your feet which sounds picky but was genuinely painful.
Overall though great and within a few miles of downtown Sarasota too.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks again for staying with us Mike! The condo association is addressing the wiring issue which impacted your use of the outdoor fan and light. I am glad to hear you were able to enjoy the great water views from the dock. That is such a relaxing space! Please come back and see us again soon!
Be prepared to bring own toilet paper, garbage bags etc. as there were none except what was on roll and in garbage can.
Location is great and nice view of Intra-Coastal. Price was right but a few negatives in the details.
Manager was very helpful.
Dolphins came by!!!
Master suite had a slight urine odor.
Missing smoke detector in kitchen.
Second bath shower handle full of mold.
Exterior of Bay Oaks very clean and nicely landscaped. Quiet, convenient.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you Andrea! It was a pleasure to host your stay and we hope to see your family again soon!
We were centrally located and our unit was very nice. My only complaint is that the master bedroom tub floor is very bumpy and almost soft feeling. After reading other reviews it appears it has been a problem for a while now.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for your observation, which I have forwarded to the owner to be addressed. We appreciate your choosing Rent Siesta Key and hope to see you again soon! UPDATE: Tub has been replaced
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for choosing Rent Siesta Key Jacqueline! We hope to see you again soon!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyLinda it was a pleasure to host your stay. Please come back any time!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyCarrie thank you for staying with us at Rent Siesta Key. We are so glad to hear you loved the home and enjoyed yourself. Thank you for mentioning the great mattress in the master and extra beach gear! We have notified the owner of your report on the master shower and will have guest services locate the master tv remote. Please come back and see us again soon! UPDATE: Tub has been replaced
Response from Rent Siesta Key¡Gracias por molestarnos en Rent Siesta Key Melisa! Fue un placer alojar su estancia. Por favor vuelve a visitarnos pronto!
The location is good but wish there were closer beach accesses. This is nothing the condo owner can do, but important to note for other travelers. We ended up driving to the beach access 12 every morning since the walk was too long for the kids. There are tips only rides you can take and the trolley, but out of convenience and to carry the beach stuff it was easier to drive.
The WiFi is really bad. The Internet speed is fine, but you basically have to stay in the master bedroom to keep a consistent connection (tried on multiple devices). The cost of a decent router is so cheap, this should not be a problem people should have.
We ended up having to clean a bunch of dishes when we got there. There were about a dozen bowls, mugs, and utensils with caked on melted cheese. Not sure what the previous guests were doing with so much cheese but they obviously didn't take the time to clean up. We also found a half eaten hot dog in the fridge. Wish the cleaner spent a little extra time to give the fridge and cupboards a once over.
Overall we were happy with our stay.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for Choosing Rent Siesta Key, Stephen, and for taking the time to leave a detailed review for the benefit of future guests! We understand it was easier for your family to drive to a beach access, beach access 12 is located 1.5 miles south of the complex. We will look into adjusting the wifi router location to provide better coverage within the home per your suggestion however you may have been attempting to connect to the communities Wifi and not the unit's. Also, please feel free to contact us if, during a future visit, you notice anything the cleaners and inspection team missed. We would be happy to send a team to resolve an issue in order to free you up to enjoy your time in Siesta Key. Please come back and visit us soon Stephen. We would love to host your return stay!
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for choosing to stay at Bay Oaks - E01. The tub has since been replaced.
But the water pressure was great and it never caused a problem. The bottom of the tub just didn't feel solid. I kept reminding myself it was working fine! This place was quaint but efficient and a place I would go back to for the price of rental. I never spoke with the management company, because all our transactions were online. However, they were very efficient and easy to deal with. I hate that my comments sound negative, because in truth this condo is not a bad place at all for the price.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for staying and glad you enjoyed your stay. The bath tub is the final piece left for the insurance company to repair from the damage cause by the unit upstairs.
The location was good, it's easy to call the free taxis and walk (to public beach access 12) or drive to the beach.
If you're looking for something modern and flashy, it's not for you. But if you're looking for a modest place to stay it's great. The kitchen supplies could be updated - pans, wine glasses.
Overall would recommend.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for choosing to stay at Bay Oaks E01. This community is always a quiet retreat on Siesta Key. Your suggestion of new kitchenware has been brought to the owners attention.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for staying and the review.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyGlad to hear you enjoyed your stay. I have not received any complaints yet about the twin beds and look into what we can do there. The sleeper sofa is a sleeper sofa, not necessary made to be the most comfortable. There is a memory foam mattress topper for it in the closet.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for choosing to stay at Bay Oaks E01 for your visit to Siesta Key and glad to hear you enjoyed your stay.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for staying at our Siesta Key condo. We are pleased to hear you enjoyed your stay. You can utilize the many free ride (tips only) services on the key to get to and from the beach.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for staying. This property is located on the inter-coastal side of the island which situates it just across the street from the beach however public beach access in either 1/2 mile south or 1 miles north. There are several free ride service (tips only) around the island you can utilize to get you to and from the beach and village.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for staying. Glad you enjoyed our condo. Wish we could have reach an all 5 star experience for you. Please let us know next time how we can achieve this.
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThanks for staying at our unit. We strive to ensure there are no issues at the unit and is clean for you to enjoy your visit to Siesta key
Response from Rent Siesta KeyThank you for staying and the great review. We look forward to accommodating you in the near future.